In 13 years, ATLAW has handled more than 10,000 cases for injured people in Michigan and recovered more than $100 million for them. The results below are a selection from those cases, and more will be added. Each lists the type of case, the county where it arose, and how it ended, so you can find the cases that resemble yours.
Two things to read before the numbers. First, every amount shown is the gross recovery, before attorney fees, case costs, and the repayment of medical liens; what a client takes home is less, and the section on fees and liens below explains how much less and why. Second, no past result predicts a future one. Michigan law caps some damages and not others, limits recovery to the at-fault driver’s insurance in most crash cases, and reduces or bars recovery when the injured person shares fault. The same injury can resolve for very different amounts depending on facts that have nothing to do with how badly someone was hurt. The section on what drives case value explains those facts.
Selected results
| Amount (gross) | Case | County | How it resolved |
|---|---|---|---|
| $833,101 | Vehicle component explosion, eye injury | Wayne | Settlement |
| About $1.27 million | No-fault (PIP) benefits | Wayne | Benefits recovered and settlement |
| $510,929 | Catastrophic injury, attendant care (no-fault) | Wayne | Settlement |
$833,101 for a vehicle component explosion that caused a serious eye injury. The amount is all payments combined, and the case was resolved by settlement in Wayne County.
About $1.27 million in no-fault benefits. Before the case settled, the firm recovered about $467,000 in personal injury protection benefits for the client: wage loss, replacement services, and attendant care. The remaining claim against the no-fault insurer then settled for $800,000. The case was in Wayne County.
$510,929 for a client whose no-fault insurer cut his round-the-clock attendant care to eight hours a day. We filed suit in Wayne County to recover the benefits, and the case settled.
Amounts are gross recoveries before attorney fees, costs, and liens. Each case depends on its own facts; these results do not predict the outcome of any other case.
What these results mean, and what they do not
A settlement is an agreement; a verdict is a decision. Most Michigan injury cases settle, often after suit is filed and the insurer has seen the medical records and depositions, sometimes at a court-ordered case evaluation or facilitation. A jury verdict is the amount a jury awarded after trial; the judgment entered on it may be higher, with interest and costs, or lower after reductions for the plaintiff’s share of fault or statutory caps, and it may be appealed. An arbitration award is a decision by a private arbitrator, common in uninsured and underinsured motorist claims where the policy requires it. Where a result says “policy limits,” the insurer paid the full amount of coverage available, which is the most it can be made to pay regardless of what the injury was worth.
Gross is not net. Michigan court rules cap the contingency fee in personal injury cases at one-third of the amount recovered, after case costs are deducted (MCR 8.121). Case costs, such as filing fees, record charges, deposition transcripts, and expert witnesses, are repaid from the recovery, and in a litigated case with experts they can be substantial. Medical providers, health insurers, Medicare, and Medicaid that paid for crash-related treatment usually have a right to be repaid from a third-party recovery, under federal law for Medicare (42 USC 1395y(b)(2)) and Michigan law for Medicaid (MCL 400.106), and ERISA health plans assert reimbursement under their plan terms. Part of a lawyer’s work on any case is reducing those liens before distribution. Ask any firm you consult to show you, in writing, how the fee, costs, and liens would come out of a hypothetical recovery.
The amount reflects the coverage as much as the injury. See below.
What drives case value in Michigan
Michigan is a no-fault state with its own rules, and several of them explain why two people with the same injury can recover very different amounts.
No-fault benefits come first, from your own insurer, regardless of fault. Under MCL 500.3107, your own policy pays medical expenses up to the PIP level you selected ($50,000 for Medicaid enrollees, $250,000, $500,000, or unlimited since the 2019 reform), 85 percent of lost wages for up to three years (capped at $7,201 a month for the year beginning October 2025), replacement services at $20 a day, and attendant care. These are paid as bills come due, not as a lump sum, so they rarely appear as a “settlement” unless the insurer denied them and the firm sued. A no-fault case result is usually the recovery of denied or cut-off benefits plus 12 percent penalty interest under MCL 500.3142 and attorney fees under MCL 500.3148.
The claim against the at-fault driver requires a threshold injury. Under MCL 500.3135, you can sue the at-fault driver for pain and suffering only if you suffered death, a serious impairment of body function, or permanent serious disfigurement. Economic losses beyond what no-fault pays (wages above the monthly cap or beyond three years, for example) can also be claimed. If the injury does not meet the threshold, there is no pain-and-suffering claim, however real the pain.
The at-fault driver’s policy limits are usually the ceiling. Michigan’s minimum liability coverage is $50,000 per person and $100,000 per crash under MCL 500.3009(1), and many drivers carry the minimum; a severe injury caused by a minimally insured driver recovers $50,000 from that driver’s insurer unless the driver has personal assets, which is rare. Underinsured motorist coverage on your own policy pays the difference up to your UIM limit; uninsured motorist coverage stands in for a driver with no insurance or a hit-and-run. Whether a client bought UM/UIM coverage, and how much, is often the single largest factor in the size of a crash recovery. Commercial trucks carry federal minimums of $750,000 and often far more (49 CFR 387.9), which is why truck-crash results tend to be larger than car-crash results for similar injuries.
Fault is shared, and it reduces the recovery. Under MCL 600.2959 and 500.3135(2)(b), a plaintiff’s damages are reduced by the plaintiff’s percentage of fault, and a plaintiff more than 50 percent at fault recovers no pain-and-suffering damages at all. A disputed left turn or a pedestrian outside a crosswalk changes the number.
Some damages are capped; most are not. Michigan has no cap on pain-and-suffering damages in car, truck, premises, or dog-bite cases. Medical malpractice noneconomic damages are capped under MCL 600.1483 at $596,400 for 2026, or $1,065,000 for the most severe categories of injury, adjusted each year. Claims against government entities (a city bus, a county road) are allowed only within narrow exceptions to governmental immunity under the Governmental Tort Liability Act (MCL 691.1401 et seq.), and some carry written notice deadlines as short as 120 days.
The injury type and the medical record. Documented objective injury, consistent treatment, and a clear causal link to the crash in the records drive value; gaps in treatment, prior similar complaints, and symptoms with no imaging to support them reduce it. This is why we tell every client to see a doctor the day of the crash and keep every appointment.
Who the defendant is. A premises case against a national retailer with a $5 million policy and a premises case against a homeowner with a $100,000 policy are valued differently. A dog bite in Michigan is strict liability under MCL 287.351, but the recovery is almost always the homeowner’s or renter’s policy limit.
Time. Cases that settle before suit resolve faster for less; cases tried to verdict take two to three years and carry the risk of a defense verdict. The right choice depends on the facts, the coverage, and what the client needs.
What “average settlement” searches get wrong
People search for the average car accident settlement in Michigan, and websites supply numbers, usually $15,000 to $30,000 for a “minor” injury and six figures for a “serious” one, with no source. There is no public database of Michigan settlements; nearly all are confidential. The published figures are either a firm’s own selected results or an estimate. The honest answer is that a Michigan crash claim is worth the lesser of what the injury would be valued at by a jury in that county and the insurance available to pay it, reduced by any share of fault, and that the only way to know is to have a lawyer review the police report, the medical records, and every policy that might apply. That review is free.
Practice areas these results come from
Each practice page explains how that kind of case works in Michigan: car accidents, truck accidents, no-fault insurance claims, uninsured and underinsured motorist claims, motorcycle accidents, pedestrian accidents, premises liability, product liability, brain injuries, medical malpractice, wrongful death, dog bites, workers’ compensation, and Social Security disability.











