Shoulder dystocia is the obstetric emergency that happens after the baby’s head is born: the front shoulder lodges behind the mother’s pubic bone and the body does not follow. The umbilical cord is compressed in the birth canal, the baby cannot breathe, and the physician has a few minutes to free the shoulder using a trained sequence of maneuvers. Done correctly, most shoulder dystocias end with a healthy baby. Done incorrectly, or too slowly, they end with a torn brachial plexus, a fractured collarbone or arm, a brain injured by lack of oxygen, or a baby who does not survive, and often with serious injury to the mother.
The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists puts the incidence at 0.2 to 3 percent of vaginal deliveries. Michigan recorded 99,420 births in 2024, about two-thirds of them vaginal, which means somewhere between a few hundred and roughly two thousand Michigan deliveries a year involve a shoulder dystocia. Most are resolved in under a minute by McRoberts positioning and suprapubic pressure and leave no trace but a line in the delivery note.
What distinguishes a shoulder dystocia case from a shoulder dystocia is what the physician and nurses did when the shoulder stuck. ACOG says plainly that shoulder dystocia cannot be reliably predicted or prevented, and defense lawyers quote that sentence in every case. It is true, and it is beside the point. The standard of care is not that the shoulder never sticks; it is that when it does, the team recognizes it, calls for help, works through the maneuvers in sequence, never pushes on the top of the uterus, never pulls hard on the baby’s head, and documents what it did and when. Every one of those steps leaves a record. This page explains what the standard required, the injuries to the baby and to the mother, how a Michigan case is proved and defended, the damages and 2026 caps, and the deadlines.
ATLAW is a personal injury firm in Dearborn. In 13 years the firm has handled more than 10,000 cases and recovered more than $100 million for clients across Wayne, Oakland, Macomb, and Washtenaw counties. Birth injury cases are handled on contingency: no fee unless we recover money for your family, and the first conversation is free. ATLAW handles these cases and works with qualified medical experts to review each one.
Shoulder dystocia in Michigan: the numbers
| Measure | Figure | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Live births, Michigan, 2024 | 99,420 | MDHHS |
| Vaginal deliveries, Michigan, 2024 | About two-thirds of births (64.6% spontaneous, 1.9% vacuum, 0.3% forceps) | MDHHS vital statistics |
| Incidence of shoulder dystocia | 0.2% to 3% of vaginal deliveries | ACOG Practice Bulletin 178 |
| Neonatal brachial plexus palsy, all births | About 1.5 per 1,000; about half follow a recognized shoulder dystocia | ACOG Task Force on NBPP, 2014 |
| Brachial plexus injuries that persist beyond 12 months | About 15% | Same |
| Estimated fetal weight at which ACOG says cesarean should be offered | 5,000 g without diabetes; 4,500 g with diabetes | ACOG Practice Bulletin 178 |
| Risk of recurrence in a later pregnancy | Roughly 10%, with wide variation across studies | Same |
| Michigan malpractice caps, 2026 | $596,400 / $1,065,000 non-economic; economic damages uncapped | MCL 600.1483 |
| Child’s deadline (injury before age 8) | The child’s 10th birthday | MCL 600.5851(7) |
| Mother’s deadline | Two years from the malpractice, six-month discovery rule | MCL 600.5805(8), 600.5838a |
Who is at risk, and what the standard required before labor
ACOG identifies the risk factors but warns that most shoulder dystocias occur in babies of normal weight to mothers with no risk factors, which is why routine cesarean for suspected large babies is not recommended. The factors that matter:
- Macrosomia: a large baby, especially over 4,500 grams (9 lb 15 oz). The risk of dystocia rises steeply with birth weight.
- Maternal diabetes, pre-existing or gestational, which produces babies with disproportionately large shoulders and trunks relative to the head.
- A prior shoulder dystocia, particularly one that caused a brachial plexus injury.
- Operative vaginal delivery with vacuum or forceps, and a prolonged second stage.
- Maternal obesity and excessive weight gain, through their effect on fetal size.
The standard of care before labor is not to predict the unpredictable; it is to act on the risks that are known. ACOG’s own guidance says a planned cesarean should be offered when the estimated fetal weight is 5,000 grams or more in a mother without diabetes or 4,500 grams or more in a mother with diabetes, and should be discussed with a mother whose prior baby had a shoulder dystocia with a brachial plexus injury. A diabetic mother carrying a ten-pound baby who was never told any of this has a claim that begins in the prenatal record, before the delivery room.
The maneuvers, in the order they are trained
When the head delivers and the shoulder does not follow, the “turtle sign” (the head retracts against the perineum), the clock starts. Most Michigan hospitals train the sequence with the mnemonic HELPERR, and many run simulation drills, which ACOG recommends.
| Step | Maneuver | What it does |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Call for help and note the time the head delivered | Brings a second physician, additional nurses, anesthesia, and the pediatric team; starts the documented interval |
| 2 | Evaluate for episiotomy | Creates room for the internal maneuvers; does not itself free the shoulder |
| 3 | McRoberts maneuver | The mother’s thighs are flexed sharply onto her abdomen, rotating the pelvis and flattening the sacrum; resolves about 40 percent of cases alone |
| 4 | Suprapubic pressure | An assistant presses downward and to the side just above the pubic bone to push the front shoulder under it. This is pressure on the pubic bone, not the uterus |
| 5 | Delivery of the posterior arm | The physician reaches along the back arm, flexes it, and sweeps it across the chest and out, reducing the shoulder diameter |
| 6 | Rotational maneuvers (Rubin II, Woods screw, reverse Woods) | Internal pressure on the shoulders rotates them into the wider oblique diameter of the pelvis |
| 7 | Gaskin (all-fours) maneuver | The mother rolls onto hands and knees, which changes pelvic dimensions and frees the posterior shoulder |
| 8 | Last resorts | Deliberate fracture of the clavicle; the Zavanelli maneuver (pushing the head back in and performing a cesarean); symphysiotomy |
ACOG does not require the steps in one fixed order after calling for help, and many physicians go to the posterior arm early because it has a high success rate. What the standard requires is that appropriate maneuvers be used promptly, with the team moving to another maneuver when one is unsuccessful.
The two things that must never be done
The maneuvers are what the standard requires. Two actions are what it prohibits, and they are at the center of most shoulder dystocia lawsuits.
Fundal pressure. Pushing down on the top of the uterus drives the impacted shoulder harder against the pubic bone, increases the force on the brachial plexus, and can rupture the uterus. ACOG states it should not be used. It still happens, usually by a nurse acting on instinct or on a physician’s instruction, and it is frequently the mother or a family member who remembers it, because it is rarely charted.
Excessive traction on the head. Pulling the baby’s head downward and sideways to free the shoulder stretches the nerves of the brachial plexus on the side of the front shoulder. ACOG’s guidance is that the physician should avoid excessive lateral traction and should use the maneuvers instead of force. The 2014 ACOG task force report acknowledges that the forces of labor themselves can stretch the plexus, and hospitals rely on that finding in every case; the same report says the injury results from excess force, and a severe, permanent injury in a large baby after a long, documented dystocia is a pattern the records have to explain. Our Erb’s palsy page covers the injury grades and how that defense is answered.
How long is too long
While the shoulder is stuck, the cord is compressed and the baby is not getting oxygen. The baby’s blood becomes more acidic with each minute. Published studies have found that the risk of brain injury rises as the head-to-body interval lengthens, with permanent injury and death becoming substantially more likely beyond about five minutes, although a healthy baby at term can often tolerate a somewhat longer interval. ACOG does not set a hard limit; the standard is that the team move through the maneuvers without delay and that the interval be documented.
Two numbers in the delivery note therefore matter more than any other: the time the head delivered and the time the body delivered. A delivery note that omits them, or records a two-minute interval in a baby born with a pH of 6.9 and seizures, is itself evidence.
What shoulder dystocia does to the baby
| Injury | How it happens | What the record shows |
|---|---|---|
| Brachial plexus injury (Erb’s palsy, Klumpke’s palsy, total plexus palsy) | Stretch, rupture, or avulsion of the nerves from C5 to T1 on the side of the impacted shoulder | Limp arm and absent Moro reflex at birth; grade confirmed by recovery pattern, EMG, imaging, and sometimes surgery. See our Erb’s palsy page |
| Clavicle fracture | Compression against the pubic bone or deliberate fracture as a maneuver | Newborn X-ray; usually heals without consequence but documents the forces involved |
| Humerus fracture | Delivery of the posterior arm with excessive force | Newborn X-ray |
| Hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy | Cord compression during a prolonged dystocia | Cord gases, Apgar scores, seizures, MRI; eligibility for cooling within six hours. See our birth asphyxia page |
| Death | Prolonged dystocia with asphyxia | Brought as wrongful death through the malpractice procedure |
What shoulder dystocia does to the mother
The mother’s injuries are often overlooked, and her claim is separate from the child’s with its own two-year deadline.
- Postpartum hemorrhage, the most common maternal complication, from uterine atony after the prolonged second stage and the maneuvers.
- Third- and fourth-degree perineal tears and the incontinence and fistula that follow if they are not recognized and repaired properly.
- Uterine rupture, particularly where fundal pressure was used.
- Symphyseal separation and nerve injury from the extreme hip flexion of a prolonged McRoberts position.
- Bladder injury and, in the case of a Zavanelli maneuver or symphysiotomy, the complications of those procedures.
- Psychological injury, which Michigan law recognizes as part of the mother’s non-economic damages.
A mother who required a hysterectomy because of negligently managed hemorrhage after shoulder dystocia may qualify for Michigan’s higher non-economic cap if the resulting permanent loss of a reproductive organ left her unable to procreate.
Proving a Michigan shoulder dystocia case
Michigan requires proof of the standard of care, breach, causation more probable than not, and damages, MCL 600.2912a, through experts who practice the same specialty as the defendant, MCL 600.2169. In a shoulder dystocia case the records and the experts line up as follows.
The records, requested by name:
- The prenatal record: estimated fetal weights and ultrasounds, glucose testing, the mother’s weight gain, any prior shoulder dystocia, and whether a delivery-planning discussion was documented.
- The labor record and the electronic fetal monitoring archive, which shows the length of the second stage and whether vacuum or forceps were used.
- The delivery note, which ACOG says should document the time of delivery of the head and body, the maneuvers used and their sequence, which shoulder was anterior, who was present, the traction applied, the infant’s condition and cord gases, and the explanation given to the parents. A note that reads “shoulder dystocia, relieved with McRoberts and suprapubic pressure, infant to NICU” after a permanent injury is as telling as a detailed one.
- The nursing notes, which often record what the physician’s note omits, including fundal pressure, who was called and when, and the times.
- The newborn record: Apgar scores, cord gases, resuscitation, X-rays, the neurological exam, and NICU course.
- The hospital’s shoulder dystocia protocol and its simulation training records, subject to any applicable peer-review privilege.
The experts: a board-certified obstetrician on the physician’s standard of care; a labor and delivery nurse on the nursing standard, fundal pressure in particular; a maternal-fetal medicine specialist on the prenatal decisions; a pediatric neurologist or brachial plexus surgeon on the grade of the nerve injury and the force it implies; a neonatologist and pediatric neuroradiologist where there is a brain injury; and life care and economic experts.
The defense, in nearly every case, is that shoulder dystocia is unpredictable and that maternal forces, not the physician, injured the baby. The answer is not to deny either proposition but to show, from the records, that the known risks were not acted on, that the maneuvers were not performed or documented, that prohibited force was used, or that the interval was too long, and that the injury pattern is one that those failures produce.
Who is liable
- The delivering physician or midwife and their practice, for the prenatal counseling, the decision to proceed vaginally, and the management of the dystocia itself.
- The hospital, for its nurses (fundal pressure, failure to call for help, failure to note times), for its training and protocols, and for a non-employee physician under Grewe v Mt Clemens General Hospital (1978) and Markel v William Beaumont Hospital (2022) where the family looked to the hospital for care.
- Residents and the teaching hospital. Shoulder dystocia is a procedure in which an unsupervised or inexperienced resident has produced many of the reported verdicts nationally; the attending physician’s presence and the hospital’s supervision policy are in issue.
- State university hospitals, in the Court of Claims, where the claim or a qualifying notice of intention generally must be filed within six months, MCL 600.6431.
Michigan retains joint and several liability in medical malpractice where the plaintiff was without fault, MCL 600.6304(6).
What can be recovered
For the child: uncapped economic damages for surgery, therapy, equipment, future care, and lost earning capacity; non-economic damages under MCL 600.1483. For a brain injury meeting the statute’s terms, the higher cap, $1,065,000 for 2026, applies. For a brachial plexus injury, which is an injury to peripheral nerves, most cases fall under the lower cap, $596,400.
For the mother: medical expenses, lost wages, future treatment, and non-economic damages for pain, disfigurement, loss of function, and psychological injury, potentially under the higher cap where negligent care caused permanent loss of or damage to a reproductive organ resulting in an inability to procreate.
For the family: the father’s loss of consortium; in a death, the wrongful death act’s damages. Settlements for a minor require court approval under MCR 2.420 and are structured to preserve the child’s benefits.
Michigan’s procedure and deadlines
| Step | Rule | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Child’s deadline (injury before 8th birthday) | Any time before the child’s 10th birthday | MCL 600.5851(7) |
| Mother's own malpractice claim; spouse's derivative consortium claim where available Generally two years from the malpractice, subject to applicable discovery and tolling rules. | Two years from the malpractice, six-month discovery rule | MCL 600.5805(8), 600.5838a |
| Wrongful death of the baby | Generally two years, with the personal representative's additional filing period under MCL 600.5852 and applicable notice-of-intent tolling. | MCL 600.2922, 600.5852 |
| Notice of intent | Served on every defendant 182 days before suit | MCL 600.2912b |
| Affidavit of merit | Filed with the complaint | MCL 600.2912d |
| Expert qualifications | Same specialty and board certification | MCL 600.2169 |
| Lost-opportunity claims (delayed referral for the nerve injury) | Opportunity must have exceeded 50 percent | MCL 600.2912a(2) |
| State university hospitals | Court of Claims; six-month notice | MCL 600.6431 |
| Non-economic caps, 2026 | $596,400 / $1,065,000 | MCL 600.1483 |
| Settlement for a minor | Court approval | MCR 2.420 |
| Medical records | Complete record; retention seven years | MCL 333.20175 |
What to do after a shoulder dystocia
- Ask for the delivery note and the discharge summaries for mother and baby before you leave the hospital. They are the hospital’s own first account.
- Request the complete records in writing: the prenatal record, the labor record and electronic monitoring archive, the delivery and nursing notes, and the newborn record with X-rays and cord gases.
- Write down what you and anyone in the room remember: how long the shoulder was stuck, who came in, whether anyone pushed on your abdomen, how the baby looked, what was said.
- If the baby’s arm is not moving, insist on a referral to a pediatric brachial plexus program if there is no clear improvement by two months; the window for nerve surgery is three to nine months.
- Enroll in Early On (1-800-327-5966), Michigan’s free early intervention program, for any child with a persistent injury.
- Call a lawyer when an injury persists past three months. The mother’s two-year clock and a university hospital’s six-month notice run from the delivery; the child’s claim runs to the tenth birthday, but the records are only required to be kept seven years.
Why metro Detroit families call ATLAW after a shoulder dystocia
- Thirteen years, more than 10,000 cases, more than $100 million recovered.
- An honest first answer. A shoulder dystocia that was handled correctly and still injured a baby is not a case, and we say so after reading the records, not before.
- The experts the case requires: obstetrics and maternal-fetal medicine, labor and delivery nursing, pediatric neurology, brachial plexus surgery, neonatology, life care planning, and economics, with reviewing experts who meet Michigan’s same-specialty requirements (MCL 600.2169).
- Both patients, both claims, with the mother’s two-year deadline and the child’s calendared together.
- The records requested in full, including the monitoring archive, the nursing notes, and, where available, the hospital’s shoulder dystocia protocol and training records.
- Settlements structured to protect the child’s benefits, coordinated where needed with special needs planning professionals.
- Dearborn, and the whole metro area. Our office is at 3 Parklane Blvd., Suite 400W, Dearborn, MI 48126. Families come from Detroit, Dearborn, Southfield, Warren, Sterling Heights, Troy, Pontiac, Canton, Ann Arbor, and Ypsilanti. We welcome clients to our Dearborn office for a consultation. If you are unable to visit, home or hospital visits can be arranged as needed.
- Languages. Consultations and intake are available in English, Arabic, French, Mandarin, Urdu, and Spanish.
- No fee unless we recover. Contingency fee ATLAW advances case costs, so you pay nothing up front; the 33.3% attorney fee is calculated on the recovery after those costs are deducted, and if there is no recovery you owe no fee and no costs. No cost for the first conversation.











