Skip to main content

Lincoln Financial Disability Denial Lawyer

Super Lawyers Rising Star · 3 Consecutive Years

Lincoln’s denial letter may offer a second appeal. Whether you have to take it, and what it costs you in time, is written in the letter.

Lincoln Financial Group is one of the largest group disability insurers in the United States, and it became one in a single transaction. In January 2018, Lincoln Financial announced an approximately $3.3 billion transaction to acquire Liberty Life Assurance Company of Boston, including Liberty Mutual’s group benefits business. The acquisition closed on May 1, 2018. The acquired company was subsequently renamed Lincoln Life Assurance Company of Boston and merged into The Lincoln National Life Insurance Company effective October 1, 2021. Lincoln said at the time that the combined company’s share of fully insured disability sales “would be ranked number one at 14 percent” and that it would have “access to 10 million insureds.” The acquisition closed in 2018. Some workers whose disability coverage originally came through Liberty Mutual’s former group benefits business now have policies or claims associated with Lincoln Financial. The Lincoln National Life Insurance Company assumed the obligations of Lincoln Life Assurance Company of Boston through the 2021 merger. The policy documents and applicable endorsements identify the insurer responsible for an individual claim.).

Some Lincoln Financial disability plans provide more than one level of internal appeal. Under ERISA, a plan may require up to two levels of appeal before a claimant seeks judicial review. Additional voluntary appeals are subject to special protections, including tolling of applicable limitations periods while the voluntary appeal is pending. Whether another appeal is required depends on the governing plan documents and denial letter. Understanding these rules is important because missing an appeal or lawsuit deadline can jeopardize a claim. Whether the second level is mandatory or voluntary is stated in the letter, and the difference matters. A mandatory second appeal must be completed before suit can be filed; a voluntary one need not be, and taking it does not extend the deadline for suing but does add months. A claimant who does not understand which kind Lincoln has offered can lose a year, or lose the case, by choosing wrong.

This page explains who your insurer is, how Lincoln group disability claims are denied and terminated, the two-level appeal and how to handle it, the ERISA rules that govern, how the appeal is built, what happens in court, and what a Michigan disability insurance lawyer does. The general law of these claims is on our long-term disability page; this page assumes it and goes to what is particular to Lincoln.

ATLAW is a Dearborn law firm serving clients for 13 years, with more than 10,000 cases handled. The firm represents Michigan claimants in long-term disability appeals and lawsuits against group disability insurers, including claims insured by Lincoln Financial and former Liberty Mutual group policies. Each case is assigned to an ATLAW attorney, and the fee is contingent: no fee unless benefits are recovered.

Lincoln Financial: the facts

FactDetailSource
Group disability insurers The Lincoln National Life Insurance Company is a principal Lincoln group disability insurer and succeeded Lincoln Life Assurance Company of Boston following the October 1, 2021 merger. Other Lincoln entities may appear on policies depending on the coverage and jurisdiction. The specific policy controls.The Lincoln National Life Insurance Company (Fort Wayne, Indiana); Lincoln Life & Annuity Company of New YorkPolicy forms
Liberty Mutual group benefits acquisition Announced January 19, 2018; completed May 1, 2018. The approximately $3.3 billion transaction included $1.446 billion of net investment associated with group benefits. Liberty Life Assurance Company of Boston was renamed in 2019 and merged into The Lincoln National Life Insurance Company on October 1, 2021.Announced January 19, 2018; total value about $3.3 billion, of which $1.446 billion was the net investment for the group benefits business; Liberty’s individual life and annuity business reinsured to Protective Life; closing in 2018Lincoln National Corporation Form 8-K, Jan. 19, 2018
Scale after the acquisitionCombined fully insured disability sales share “ranked number one at 14 percent” (LIMRA, Dec. 31, 2016); combined life and disability sales rank number three; access to 10 million insuredsSame
Governing law for employer plansERISA; 29 CFR 2560.503-1Federal law
Claimant’s first-appeal deadlineAt least 180 days from receipt of the denial29 CFR 2560.503-1(h)(3)(i)
Insurer’s appeal decision deadline45 days, one 45-day extension29 CFR 2560.503-1(i)(3)
Two levels of appealPermitted; a second mandatory level must meet the regulation’s requirements; a voluntary level cannot be required before suit and must not affect the limitation period29 CFR 2560.503-1(c)(2), (c)(3), and (d)
Standard of review in most casesArbitrary and capricious, if the plan grants discretionFirestone v. Bruch (1989); Metropolitan Life v. Glenn (2008)
Contractual limitation periodsEnforceable if reasonable, even if running before exhaustionHeimeshoff v. Hartford (2013)
Penalty interest under a Michigan (non-ERISA) policy12% per yearMCL 500.2006

How Lincoln claims are denied and terminated

The letter saysWhat is usually behind itWhat the appeal does
“The medical documentation does not support restrictions and limitations that would preclude you from performing the material and substantial duties of your own occupation”The insurer may have relied on a review of the medical file rather than an in-person examination. The reviewing professional’s qualifications, conclusions, and explanation should be compared with the treating medical evidence.Treating-specialist opinions that answer the reviewer point by point; objective testing; the Sixth Circuit argument that rejecting treating physicians on a file review without explanation, when the plan allowed an examination, supports arbitrariness
“Your occupation, as it is performed in the national economy, is sedentary”Some disability policies define an occupation according to how it is generally performed in the national economy rather than the claimant’s specific job with an employer. The policy’s definition and the occupational evidence used by the insurer must be reviewed.A vocational assessment addressing the occupation’s material duties as generally performed, and whether the classification fits the work you did
“Effective [24-month date], the definition of disability changes to any occupation”Some policies change their disability definition after an initial own-occupation period, often 24 months. A vocational assessment may identify other occupations the claimant could perform, subject to the policy’s actual work-capacity and earnings requirements.Testing each occupation against the actual restrictions and the threshold; checking whether the capacity profile the analysis assumed came from your physicians or Lincoln’s reviewer
“Your condition falls within the mental illness limitation”Some policies limit benefits for specified mental-health conditions. Whether the limitation applies depends on its wording, the medical evidence, and the basis for the claimed disability.Evidence that the physical impairment is independently disabling; the policy’s exact language
“Benefits have been reduced by estimated Social Security disability benefits”Some LTD policies permit deductions for Social Security disability benefits or estimated benefits. Any estimated offset or reimbursement arrangement must be authorized by the policy’s specific provisions.Election of the reimbursement alternative where available; verification; coordination of the SSDI claim
“Your disability is excluded under the pre-existing condition provision”Look-back review of the months before coverageRecord-by-record analysis against the clause’s exact terms
“Surveillance activity is inconsistent with your reported limitations”Field investigation, often before a terminationContext and duration; consistency with restrictions actually claimed; treating-physician statement
“You may request a second review of this decision”A further appeal may be available under the plan. Whether that review is mandatory or voluntary must be determined from the governing documents and applicable ERISA rules.Determine from the letter and the plan whether the second level is mandatory or voluntary; calculate the effect on the limitation period before deciding
“We did not receive the requested documentation”Short-deadline requests during the claimComplete responses with proof of delivery; objection where no request was actually made

The reasons listed above are examples of issues that may arise in long-term disability denials. They do not describe every Lincoln Financial policy or establish that Lincoln uses the same reasoning in every claim.

The two-level appeal, and how to handle it

ERISA’s claims regulation permits a plan to require two levels of mandatory appeal before suit, provided each level complies with the regulation’s deadlines and the claimant is told the rules. ERISA also permits voluntary review after the plan’s required appeal procedures have been exhausted. Under 29 CFR 2560.503-1(c)(3), a qualifying voluntary appeal cannot be required before filing suit, applicable limitations periods are tolled while the voluntary review is pending, and the plan must provide sufficient information for the claimant to make an informed decision. The plan may not charge fees or costs for participating in that voluntary process.: the plan may not require it before suit, the limitation period for suing must be tolled while a voluntary appeal is pending, the claimant must be told it is voluntary and what effect it has, and the plan may not use the claimant’s decision to skip it against the claimant later.

Lincoln’s letters commonly offer a second review. The questions, in order:

  1. Is the second level mandatory or voluntary? The denial letter and the plan document say. If mandatory, it must be completed and suit cannot be filed until it is; the record stays open through the second decision. If voluntary, suit may be filed after the first appeal is denied, and the second level is a choice.
  2. If voluntary, is it worth taking? A voluntary second appeal is another chance to add evidence to the record before court, and the limitation period is tolled while it is pending. It also costs months. It is usually worth taking when there is significant evidence still to add, and not when the record is complete and the insurer’s position is fixed.
  3. What does the contractual limitation period say? Lincoln’s policies, like most, set a period for filing suit measured from when proof of claim was due. Under Heimeshoff, it is enforceable. The period is calculated at the first denial, and the appeal strategy is built around it.

The second-level question, mandatory or voluntary, should be answered before the first appeal is filed, because the answer determines whether the record stays open after the first decision and when suit can be brought.

Whichever path is taken, the first appeal is built as if it were the only one: the complete record, the treating-physician responses, the vocational evidence, the procedural objections. A thin first appeal that relies on the second to fix it is a gamble on the insurer’s generosity.

The ERISA rules Lincoln must follow

  • The denial letter must state the specific reasons and plan provisions, describe what would perfect the claim, explain the appeal procedure including whether any further level is mandatory or voluntary, state the right to sue, and, under the 2018 amendments, explain why Lincoln disagrees with the treating physicians and with any Social Security award.
  • At least 180 days to file the first appeal.
  • The complete claim file, free of charge on request, including the peer reviews, the transferable skills analysis, the surveillance, and the internal guidelines relied on.
  • New evidence developed during the appeal must be disclosed with time to respond before the appeal is decided.
  • The appeal decided by someone new, consulting a health professional not involved in the initial denial, within 45 days plus one 45-day extension at each mandatory level.
  • Violations that are more than minor cost Lincoln its deference: deemed exhaustion and de novo review under 29 CFR 2560.503-1(l)(2).

Building the appeal against Lincoln

The appeal is the trial. The federal judge reads the file as Lincoln closed it and, in most cases, asks only whether Lincoln’s decision was arbitrary and capricious.

Proving the disability

  1. Obtain and read the complete claim file. Identify the peer reviewer and specialty, the occupational classification Lincoln applied, the transferable skills analysis and its assumed capacities, and every record Lincoln did not have.
  2. Update the medical record through the appeal date.
  3. Obtain treating-specialist opinions that answer the peer reviewer point by point and state function-by-function restrictions against the policy’s definition of disability, own occupation as generally performed or any occupation at the earnings threshold.
  4. Add objective testing where the condition allows.
  5. Obtain a vocational assessment addressing the occupation as the policy defines it and each occupation in the transferable skills analysis.
  6. Include the Social Security decision and its evidence.
  7. Add statements from family, former supervisors, and coworkers.

Proving the process was unreasonable

  1. Document the reviewer’s specialty mismatch, the treating opinions ignored, and Lincoln’s unexercised right to examine.
  2. Compare the denial letter to the record.
  3. Document every procedural failure, including any failure to explain whether the second level was mandatory or voluntary.
  4. Set out the structural conflict of interest under Glenn.
  5. Write the argument tying the evidence to the policy language and the law.

If the appeal is denied

Suit is filed under 29 USC 1132(a)(1)(B) in federal court, in Michigan the Eastern District (Detroit, Ann Arbor, Flint, Bay City) or Western District (Grand Rapids, Kalamazoo, Lansing, Marquette), on the administrative record. If the plan grants Lincoln discretion, the standard is arbitrary and capricious with the conflict of interest weighed under Glenn; if Lincoln forfeited deference through procedural violations, de novo. Remedies are the benefits owed with interest and, in the court’s discretion, attorney fees to a claimant who achieves some success on the merits. Remand to Lincoln for a new decision is a common outcome.

For Lincoln policies not governed by ERISA, individual policies and policies issued to governmental and church employers, Michigan law applies: a jury, discovery, contract damages, and 12 percent penalty interest under MCL 500.2006 on benefits not timely paid when the claim was not reasonably in dispute.

The Social Security connection

Lincoln requires claimants to apply for Social Security disability, offsets the LTD benefit by the award (and by an estimate before the award, absent a reimbursement agreement), and demands repayment of the overlap when back pay arrives. The SSDI award is also evidence of disability that the 2018 ERISA rules require Lincoln to address in its denial letter; an insurer that required the application, took the offset, and disregarded the result has created the inconsistency courts weigh in finding arbitrariness. Our SSDI page covers the Social Security claim; the two are handled together.

What to do when Lincoln denies or terminates your claim

  1. Note the date you received the letter and count 180 days.
  2. Read the letter for the second-level appeal language: mandatory or voluntary, and the deadline for each.
  3. Read the policy for the contractual limitation period and calculate the deadline for suit from the date proof of claim was due.
  4. Request the complete claim file in writing, citing 29 CFR 2560.503-1(h)(2)(iii), and wait for it before appealing.
  5. Respond to every information request completely, with proof of delivery.
  6. Do not sign a reimbursement agreement, release, or buyout without advice.
  7. Keep treating, and assume surveillance.
  8. Call a lawyer before the first appeal is filed. Build it as the only one.

What a disability insurance lawyer does against this insurer

  • Determines whether ERISA or Michigan law governs, whether the plan grants discretion, whether the second appeal level is mandatory or voluntary, and when the contractual limitation period runs.
  • Obtains the claim file and dissects the peer review, the occupational classification, and the transferable skills analysis.
  • Builds the twelve-part appeal, decides with the client whether to take a voluntary second level, and submits every filing with proof of delivery before the deadline.
  • Coordinates the Social Security claim and manages the estimated offset and the repayment demand.
  • Litigates in federal court on the record, or in Michigan court with a jury for non-ERISA policies, and seeks fees and penalty interest where available.

Long-term disability appeals and lawsuits are handled on a contingency basis: no fee unless benefits are recovered. ATLAW advances case-related expenses, and the fee terms are explained in a written fee agreement before work begins. There is no charge for the initial consultation.

Why Michigan claimants call ATLAW for Lincoln and Liberty Mutual denials

  • Thirteen years serving clients, more than 10,000 cases.
  • The first appeal built as the only one, with the record complete before Lincoln closes it.
  • Social Security and LTD coordinated, including the estimated offset.
  • Dearborn, and the whole metro area. Our office is at 3 Parklane Blvd., Suite 400W, Dearborn, MI 48126. Clients come from Detroit, Dearborn, Southfield, Warren, Sterling Heights, Troy, Pontiac, Canton, Ann Arbor, and Ypsilanti. We welcome clients to our Dearborn office for a consultation. If you are unable to visit, home or hospital visits can be arranged as needed.
  • Languages. Consultations and intake are available in English, Arabic, French, Mandarin, Urdu, and Spanish.
  • Fees. Long-term disability appeals and lawsuits are handled on contingency: no fee unless benefits are recovered. ATLAW advances case-related expenses, and the fee terms are explained in a written fee agreement before work begins. The initial consultation is free.

Trusted by Clients. Rated 5 Stars.

Every testimonial represents a life changed.

From the very beginning, they made me feel like family and truly cared about every detail. Dewnya made me feel like I was her sister — she is always responsive, listens with genuine care, and makes you feel comfortable and understood. Mazen is always supportive, keeps me updated, and treats you like family, not just a client. I'm truly grateful for their kindness, humanity, and professionalism. Highly recommend.

ESEsmahanGoogle Review

I had a very positive experience working with the best lawyer Dewnya Bazzi and her entire teames. From the beginning of my case, they were professional, knowledgeable, responsive, and genuinely caring. They took the time to explain everything clearly, answered my questions, and kept me informed throughout the process.I especially appreciate the hard work and attention to detail that everyone at the office put into my case. The entire team was respectful, patient, and made me feel that my case was in good hands.I’m very grateful for the time and effort they dedicated to helping me. I would definitely recommend lawyer Dewnya Bazzi and her team to anyone looking for professional and compassionate legal representation.

ZYZ YGoogle Review

I had an excellent experience with my attorney,Dewnya, and would highly recommend her to anyone looking for a dedicated and trustworthy lawyer. My case was complicated, and I had been turned down by two other attorneys before I found her. From the beginning, she took the time to understand my situation, listened to my concerns, and never made me feel like my case was too difficult. She was professional, knowledgeable, responsive, and most importantly, she genuinely fought for me and my best interests. She stayed persistent throughout the entire process and worked extremely hard to achieve a great result. I’m truly grateful for everything she did for me and for the way she handled my case. I couldn’t have asked for a better attorney, and I highly recommend her!

BMBmcTransportLLcGoogle Review

Our Clients

Dewnya presenting settlement check to client
Dewnya with client at the office
Dewnya with Vincent Rutley and family
Dewnya with clients at ATLAW office
Dewnya embracing client after case resolution
Dewnya with Ali Bakri
Dewnya with client
Dewnya with client at office
Dewnya with Josh
ATLAW team and clients group photo

Testimonials or endorsements do not constitute a guarantee, warranty, or prediction regarding the outcome of your legal matter.

Frequently Asked Questions.

Lincoln Financial acquired Liberty Mutual’s group benefits business, Liberty Life Assurance Company of Boston, in 2018. Policies written by Liberty are now administered by Lincoln, and the appeal goes to the address on the denial letter.
At least 180 days from receipt of the first denial under ERISA. If Lincoln offers a second level, the letter states its deadline and whether it is mandatory or voluntary. Separately, the policy sets a deadline for filing suit, which is enforceable under Heimeshoff; calculate it when the first denial arrives.
It depends on whether the second level is mandatory or voluntary, which the letter and the plan must say. If mandatory, yes, before suit. If voluntary, no; you may sue after the first appeal is denied, and the limitation period is tolled if you choose to take the voluntary level. The decision depends on what evidence remains to be added.
Lincoln defines own occupation by how the occupation is generally performed, classified from the Dictionary of Occupational Titles, not by your actual job. The appeal addresses the occupation’s material duties as generally performed and whether Lincoln’s classification fits the work you did; a vocational assessment is usually needed.
Lincoln relies on peer reviews by non-examining physicians. Courts in Michigan’s federal circuit have treated reliance on a file review to reject treating physicians, when the insurer had the right to examine the claimant and did not, as evidence of an arbitrary decision. The appeal makes that point with the record to support it.
Either the own-occupation period ended and Lincoln found you able to perform any occupation on a transferable skills analysis, or the mental illness limitation was applied. The letter says which; the appeal answers the specific finding.
Lincoln policies allow an estimated offset unless you sign a reimbursement agreement. Ask which alternative applies, and coordinate the SSDI application so the award, the offset, and the repayment demand are handled together.
Not under ERISA, which allows recovery of the benefits, interest, and in the court’s discretion attorney fees. Under a non-ERISA Lincoln policy governed by Michigan law, contract damages and 12 percent penalty interest are available.
Not if ERISA governs. A federal judge decides on Lincoln’s file. A jury is available only for individual, governmental, and church-plan policies under Michigan law.
Long-term disability appeals and lawsuits are handled on contingency: no fee unless benefits are recovered. ATLAW advances case-related expenses, and the fee terms are explained in a written fee agreement before work begins. The initial review is free.

Talk to a Michigan lawyer about your Lincoln Financial disability denial

If The Lincoln National Life Insurance Company, Lincoln Financial Group, or a Liberty Mutual group policy now administered by Lincoln denied or terminated your long-term disability claim anywhere in Michigan, call (313) 406-7606 or send the form on this page before your appeal deadline runs. We determine which appeals are mandatory, calculate the limitation period, obtain the claim file, build the appeal as the record the court will read, coordinate your Social Security claim, and litigate when the insurer does not relent. We respond within one business day. There is no fee unless benefits are recovered, and the initial review is free; the fee terms are explained in a written agreement before any work begins.

See How Much We Can Win for You.

Pay nothing unless we win.

Get a FREE Case Evaluation Today!

You Pay Nothing Unless We Win Your Case.

(313) 406-7606

We’re here to help.