Half of Detroit’s households rent, and renters across metro Detroit are hurt every year by conditions a landlord was obligated to fix: an unlit stairwell, a parking lot that stays iced for days, a broken entry lock, a railing that gives way, a furnace that leaks carbon monoxide, a child’s exposure to lead paint. Michigan law gives tenants two protections most do not know they have. A statute, MCL 554.139, makes every residential landlord promise that the premises and common areas are fit for their intended use and kept in reasonable repair, and a lease cannot waive it. And on July 20, 2026, the Michigan Supreme Court decided Bowerman v Red Oak Management, which rejected the “mere inconvenience” argument landlords had used for years to defeat these claims.
This page explains what your landlord owes you inside your unit and in the common areas, how the 2026 and 2023 Supreme Court decisions changed tenant cases, what to do about notice and repairs, the rules for negligent security, lead, carbon monoxide, and guests, the protection against retaliation when you complain, and the deadlines.
ATLAW is a personal injury firm in Dearborn. In 13 years the firm has handled more than 10,000 cases and recovered more than $100 million for clients across Wayne, Oakland, Macomb, and Washtenaw counties. Tenant cases are handled on contingency: no fee unless we recover money for you, and the first conversation is free.
Renting and injury in Michigan
| Measure | Figure | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Detroit households that own their home | 50.3%; the rest rent | U.S. Census, 2020–2024 ACS |
| Median gross rent, Detroit | $1,074 a month | U.S. Census, 2020–2024 ACS |
| Fall injuries treated in Michigan emergency rooms, 2024 | 236,773 | Michigan Falls Prevention Week proclamation, 2026 |
| Fall hospitalizations, 2024 | 26,611 | Same |
| Fall deaths, 2024 | 1,701, of which 1,544 were age 65 or older | Same |
Stairs, walkways, and parking lots at rental properties are where a large share of those falls happen (a fall on the public sidewalk in front of the building is a different case, covered on our sidewalk injury page), and older tenants in senior housing, the population in Bowerman, are the most vulnerable.
What your landlord owes you: MCL 554.139
Every residential lease in Michigan includes two promises by the landlord, whether or not the lease mentions them (MCL 554.139(1)):
- (a) That the premises and all common areas are fit for the use intended by the parties.
- (b) To keep the premises in reasonable repair during the lease and to comply with the applicable health and safety laws of the state and the local unit of government, except where the disrepair was caused by the tenant’s willful or irresponsible conduct.
The statute says it “shall be liberally construed” in favor of tenants (554.139(3)). These covenants sit on top of the ordinary duties every property owner owes, which are explained on our premises liability and slip and fall pages. The covenants can be modified only in a lease with a term of at least one year (554.139(2)), and Michigan’s Truth in Renting Act separately prohibits any lease clause that excuses the landlord from liability for its own negligence or for failing to perform a duty imposed by law (MCL 554.633(1)(e)). A clause in your lease saying the landlord is not responsible for injuries is void.
Common areas are the parts of the property the landlord controls and two or more tenants share: hallways, stairwells, entries, laundry rooms, parking lots, walkways, and trash areas (Allison v AEW Capital Management, 2008). The fitness covenant applies to them; the reasonable-repair covenant applies to the leased premises. The Michigan Supreme Court has held that the reasonable-repair covenant does not reach common areas, so a common-area claim is a fitness claim (Allison; Bowerman v Red Oak Management, 2026).
The July 2026 decision: Bowerman v Red Oak Management
For eighteen years, landlords defended common-area cases with a sentence from Allison: a condition that is a “mere inconvenience of access” does not make a common area unfit. Parking lots with one to two inches of snow were held fit for parking; walkways with hazards tenants could step around were held fit for walking.
In Bowerman, a 75-year-old resident of an apartment building for elderly and disabled tenants fractured her ankle stepping into a ten-foot trench, four inches deep, left uncovered and unmarked next to the trash dumpster for nearly three weeks after a contractor replaced a concrete pad. The trial court and the Court of Appeals dismissed her claim under 554.139 as a mere inconvenience. On July 20, 2026, the Michigan Supreme Court reversed. The holdings that matter for every tenant case:
- Fitness is measured by the use the parties intended. Because the building housed elderly and disabled residents, the landlord had to ensure they had reasonable access to a means of disposing of their trash. The tenant population is part of the standard.
- “Mere inconvenience” is not a test. The Court said the phrase had become “a trapdoor in the analysis.” Whether a hazard is an inconvenience of access “may be relevant, but it is not dispositive.”
- Liberal construction means what it says. The Court applied 554.139(3) in the tenant’s favor.
- The contractor is liable too. The company that dug the trench and left it unmarked could be sued for ordinary negligence even after it left the site, and the tenant’s own knowledge of the trench goes to comparative fault, not to whether the contractor breached its duty.
The Court declined to decide whether the remedy for a breach of MCL 554.139 is limited to contract remedies and left that question for the trial court on remand. For a tenant injured in a common area in Michigan today, the practical effect is that a case dismissed under Allison in 2024 is a jury question in 2026.
The 2023 decision: open and obvious is no longer a bar
Tenant cases were also dismissed for two decades because the hazard was “open and obvious.” In Kandil-Elsayed v F & E Oil (July 28, 2023), the Supreme Court held that the obviousness of a hazard goes to the landlord’s breach and the tenant’s comparative fault, both for a jury, and that a landlord should anticipate harm from an obvious hazard a tenant must confront, such as the only route to the parking lot, the mailbox, or the trash. Bowerman applied that rule to its facts. The combination of the two decisions is the reason this page exists: tenant injury law in Michigan is more favorable to tenants than it has been since the 1990s.
Inside your unit: notice, repairs, and negligent work
Inside the leased unit, the landlord is not in possession, so its liability depends on knowledge and repair:
- Defects the landlord knew or should have known about and failed to repair within a reasonable time after notice are a breach of the reasonable-repair covenant (554.139(1)(b)) and of the Michigan Housing Law’s requirement that owners keep dwellings in good repair (MCL 125.471). Written repair requests, texts, emails, and portal tickets are the evidence; keep every one, and send repair requests in writing even when the manager prefers calls.
- Hidden defects that existed at move-in and that the landlord knew of are the landlord’s responsibility to disclose.
- Repairs the landlord undertook and did poorly are ordinary negligence whoever performed them, and the contractor is a defendant in its own right (Bowerman).
- Code violations found by a city inspector are evidence of negligence. Detroit, Dearborn, Southfield, Warren, and most metro cities require rental registration and periodic inspection; the inspection file, obtained by Freedom of Information Act request, often shows the defect was cited before you were hurt.
Negligent security in apartment buildings
A landlord is not an insurer against crime, and Michigan imposes no general duty on landlords or merchants to provide security against it. Michigan’s Supreme Court has held that landlords and merchants are not required to anticipate crime in general (MacDonald v PKT, 2001), and that a landlord’s duty is the narrow one to respond reasonably to an imminent criminal act in a common area of which it has notice, which ordinarily means calling the police (Bailey v Schaaf, 2013). Security measures a landlord chooses to provide, such as cameras, a guard, or a gate, generally do not create a broader duty. The claims that remain are narrow: a landlord that had notice of an attack under way in a lobby or hallway and did nothing, or a common-area condition that breached the 554.139 covenants, such as a broken entry door or lock the landlord was told about and left unrepaired, or lighting out for weeks. Police calls-for-service records, prior incident reports, and your own complaints are the evidence.
Lead paint, carbon monoxide, and fire
- Lead. Most of metro Detroit’s rental housing predates the 1978 lead paint ban. Federal law requires landlords to disclose known lead hazards and provide the EPA pamphlet before a lease (42 USC 4852d), and Michigan’s lead abatement law and local ordinances regulate lead-safe conditions in rentals (MCL 333.5451 and following). A child’s elevated blood lead level traced to deteriorated paint, dust, or soil at a rental is a negligence and 554.139 claim against the landlord, with lifelong damages.
- Carbon monoxide and smoke detectors. State law requires a smoke alarm in every unit of a multiple dwelling and in pre-1974 homes (MCL 125.482a, 125.1504c), and carbon monoxide alarms near bedrooms, attached garages, and fuel-burning appliances when a home is built, renovated under permit, or gains a bedroom (MCL 125.1504f); local codes often go further. A furnace, water heater, or space heater that leaks carbon monoxide, or a fire in a unit without working alarms, is a 554.139(1)(b) and code-violation case.
- Bedbugs, mold, and sewage. Habitability conditions that cause illness are claims under the fitness and repair covenants and the Housing Law, proved with medical records, inspection reports, and the repair-request history.
Guests and visitors of tenants
A tenant’s guest cannot sue under MCL 554.139, which runs to the tenant, but has a premises-liability claim against the landlord for common areas the landlord controls. A guest injured inside the unit by a condition the tenant controlled may have a claim against the tenant’s renters insurance; a guest injured by a condition the landlord was obligated to repair has a claim against the landlord.
Public housing and subsidized housing
If your landlord is a housing commission (the Detroit Housing Commission, for example), it is a governmental agency. Your claim for a defective condition of the building proceeds under the public building exception to governmental immunity (MCL 691.1406), with written notice to the agency within 120 days of the injury. A private landlord who accepts Section 8 vouchers is an ordinary defendant, and HUD’s housing quality standards and the inspection reports they generate are evidence of the standard of care.
Your landlord cannot retaliate for your complaint
Tenants hesitate to report hazards or pursue claims because they fear eviction. Michigan law prohibits a landlord from evicting a tenant in retaliation for complaining to a government agency about conditions, for exercising rights under the lease or the law, or for membership in a tenant organization; where the tenant complained through a court or government agency within the 90 days before the eviction case was filed, the eviction is presumed retaliatory unless the landlord proves otherwise (MCL 600.5720). Reporting a dangerous condition to the city and to the landlord in writing is protected, and it is also the notice the injury case will need.
Your own fault
Michigan’s comparative fault statute reduces your pain-and-suffering recovery by your percentage of fault and bars it above 50% (MCL 600.2959). After Kandil-Elsayed and Bowerman, your knowledge of the hazard is argued here, not used to dismiss the case. The answer in most tenant cases is the same one the Supreme Court gave: a tenant who must use the stairwell, the walkway, or the trash area to live in their home has no alternative, and the landlord was obligated to make it fit for that use.
Evidence in a tenant injury case
| Evidence | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Written repair requests, texts, emails, portal tickets | Notice to the landlord and the date it began |
| Photographs and video of the condition, dated | The defect as it existed; conditions are repaired after an injury |
| City rental inspection reports and violation notices (FOIA) | Prior notice; code violations as evidence of negligence |
| The lease and any addenda | The intended use, the parties, the term, and any clause the Truth in Renting Act voids |
| Other tenants’ complaints and statements | Notice and duration |
| Police calls for service and incident reports (security cases) | Foreseeability and notice |
| Weather records (snow and ice cases) | Timing of the storm and the landlord’s response |
| Maintenance contracts and the contractor’s identity | Additional defendants (Bowerman) |
| Your medical records and photographs of injuries | Damages |
What to do after you are hurt at your rental
- Report the condition to the landlord in writing the same day, with photographs, even if you reported it before. Keep a copy.
- Photograph and measure the hazard before it is fixed.
- Get medical care and describe where and how you were hurt.
- Request the city’s rental inspection file or let us do it.
- Do not sign anything from the landlord’s insurer, and do not give a recorded statement before speaking to a lawyer.
- Do not withhold rent as a remedy for the injury; it invites an eviction and complicates the case. Rent-escrow remedies for repairs are a separate matter we can advise on.
- Call a tenant injury lawyer. Preservation letters, the FOIA request, and identification of the management company, the owner, and any contractor come first.
What a Michigan tenant injury case is worth
Medical expenses, lost wages and earning capacity, pain and suffering, loss of enjoyment of life, scarring, and in a death the damages under the wrongful death act (MCL 600.2922), reduced by any fault assigned to you. There is no serious impairment threshold; that rule belongs to motor vehicle cases. The defendants are the owner, the management company, and often a maintenance, snow-removal, or security contractor, each with its own liability policy, which is why tenant cases are more fully collectible than most injury claims.
Deadlines for Michigan tenant injury claims
| Deadline | Time | Statute |
|---|---|---|
| Personal injury lawsuit against a landlord, manager, or contractor | 3 years from the injury | MCL 600.5805(2) |
| Wrongful death | 3 years, with saving provisions for the estate | MCL 600.5805, 600.5852 |
| Claim against a housing commission (public building exception) | Written notice within 120 days; suit within 2 years | MCL 691.1406, 691.1411 |
| Child’s claim (lead exposure, injuries to minors) | Until the child’s 19th birthday | MCL 600.5851 |
| Breach of the statutory covenant pleaded in contract | 6 years; whether personal-injury damages are available on a contract theory remains open after Bowerman (2026) | MCL 600.5807 |
| Retaliatory eviction presumption | 90 days after the protected act | MCL 600.5720 |
Why metro Detroit tenants call ATLAW
- Thirteen years, more than 10,000 cases, more than $100 million recovered.
- Current law. Every tenant case is evaluated under Bowerman (2026) and Kandil-Elsayed (2023), not under the dismissal rules landlords’ insurers still cite.
- Every responsible party. Owner, management company, and contractors identified from the lease, the county register of deeds, and the city’s rental registration.
- Protection from retaliation. We advise on your rights as a tenant while the injury case proceeds and, where needed, refer housing matters to housing counsel.
- Dearborn, and the whole metro area. Our office is at 3 Parklane Blvd., Suite 400W, Dearborn, MI 48126. Clients come from Detroit, Dearborn, Southfield, Warren, Sterling Heights, Troy, Pontiac, Canton, Ann Arbor, and Ypsilanti. We welcome clients to our Dearborn office for a consultation. If you are unable to visit, home or hospital visits can be arranged as needed.
- Languages. Consultations and intake are available in English, Arabic, French, Mandarin, Urdu, and Spanish.
- No fee unless we recover. ATLAW advances case costs, so you pay nothing up front; the 33.3% attorney fee is calculated on the recovery after those costs are deducted, and if there is no recovery you owe no fee and no costs. No cost for the first conversation.












