Unum Group, based in Chattanooga, Tennessee, is one of the largest disability insurers in the United States. Its subsidiaries, principally Unum Life Insurance Company of America for group policies, with Provident Life and Accident Insurance Company, The Paul Revere Life Insurance Company, and First Unum Life Insurance Company for individual and New York business, provide disability coverage to millions of American workers. If your employer offers long-term disability coverage, there is a fair chance the policy says Unum.
Unum is also the company whose claims handling produced one of the most significant regulatory actions in disability insurance history. In November 2004, after a multistate market conduct examination led by the insurance regulators of Maine, Massachusetts, and Tennessee, Unum’s subsidiaries entered into Regulatory Settlement Agreements that 48 states and the District of Columbia adopted, with the U.S. Department of Labor as a party. Unum paid a $15 million fine, agreed to offer reassessment of qualifying claims denied or terminated between January 1, 1997 and January 2005, a process that began with notices to about 215,000 claimants and ended with about 23,000 claims reassessed, and agreed to specific changes in how it evaluated claims, including how it treated the opinions of treating physicians and the significance of Social Security disability awards, under a monitoring regime that carried a contingent fine of $145 million if a follow-up examination found reassessment error rates above the 7 percent tolerance standard (the 2008 examination found rates of 4 percent or less, and no fine was assessed). In October 2005 the California Department of Insurance, which had declined to join the multistate agreement, imposed its own $8 million penalty and a separate reassessment for about 26,000 California claimants. When the reassessment closed in December 2007, the regulators’ final report found that 41.7 percent of the reassessed claims had been reversed in whole or in part, with about $676 million in additional benefits paid or reserved.
That was twenty years ago, and the company has changed. The reason the history still belongs on this page is that the practices the regulators identified in 2004, denials resting on in-house physicians’ file reviews, treating physicians’ opinions discounted without explanation, Social Security awards disregarded, claims closed at the own-occupation transition, are the same categories of conduct that an ERISA court weighs today in deciding whether a denial was arbitrary and capricious. A Michigan claimant whose denial letter from Unum fits one of those patterns is not inventing a grievance; she is describing something a state insurance commissioner once documented.
This page explains who your insurer is, how Unum claims are denied and terminated, the ERISA rules that govern the appeal, how the appeal is built, what happens in court, and what a Michigan disability insurance lawyer does. The general law of these claims is on our long-term disability page; this page assumes it and goes to what is particular to Unum.
ATLAW is a Dearborn law firm serving clients for 13 years, with more than 10,000 cases handled. The firm represents Michigan claimants in long-term disability appeals and lawsuits against group disability insurers, including claims insured by Unum. Each case is assigned to an ATLAW attorney, and the fee is contingent: no fee unless benefits are recovered.
Unum: the facts
| Fact | Detail | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Parent and headquarters | Unum Group, Chattanooga, Tennessee | Unum Group filings |
| Group disability issuing entity | Unum Life Insurance Company of America, Portland, Maine | Policy forms |
| Other disability subsidiaries | Provident Life and Accident Insurance Company (individual); The Paul Revere Life Insurance Company; First Unum Life Insurance Company (New York) | Same |
| 2004 multistate Regulatory Settlement Agreements | November 2004; led by Maine, Massachusetts, Tennessee; adopted by 48 states and D.C. U.S. Department of Labor a party; $15 million fine; claims-handling and governance changes; claim reassessment for claims denied or closed from January 1, 1997; contingent fine of $145 million for non-compliance | UnumProvident Form 10-K for 2005 and related filings |
| Reassessment scope | Eligibility notices to claimants denied January 2000 through November 2004; amended to add about 29,500 claimants from 1997–1999; a separate offer to about 24,000 private-label, acquired, and reinsured-block claimants | Same |
| 2005 California settlement | October 2005; $8.0 million civil penalty; reassessment notices to about 26,000 Californians denied or terminated January 1, 1997 through September 30, 2005; California-specific policy changes | UnumProvident Form 10-K for 2005 |
| Financial charge for the multistate settlement | After-tax charge of $87.8 million in 2004 | UnumProvident Form 8-K, 2005 |
| Governing law for employer plans | ERISA; 29 CFR 2560.503-1 | Federal law |
| Claimant’s appeal deadline | At least 180 days from receipt of the denial | 29 CFR 2560.503-1(h)(3)(i) |
| Insurer’s appeal decision deadline | 45 days, one 45-day extension | 29 CFR 2560.503-1(i)(3) |
| Standard of review in most cases | Arbitrary and capricious if the plan validly grants discretion; however, Michigan prohibits discretionary clauses in covered insurance policies, which may require de novo review. | Firestone v. Bruch (1989); Metropolitan Life v. Glenn (2008) |
| Penalty interest under a Michigan (non-ERISA) policy | 12% per year | MCL 500.2006 |
How Unum claims are denied and terminated
| The letter says | What is usually behind it | What the appeal does |
|---|---|---|
| “The medical information in your file does not support restrictions and limitations that would prevent you from performing the material and substantial duties of your regular occupation” | A review by one of Unum’s in-house or retained physicians who read the file and did not examine you; the 2004 agreements specifically addressed Unum’s reliance on these reviews over treating physicians | Treating-specialist opinions that answer the reviewer point by point; objective testing; the Sixth Circuit argument that rejecting treating physicians on a file review without explanation, when the plan allowed an examination, supports arbitrariness |
| “Your regular occupation, as it is normally performed in the national economy, is sedentary” | Unum defines “regular occupation” by how the occupation is generally performed, not by your job, and classifies it from the Dictionary of Occupational Titles | A vocational assessment addressing the occupation’s material and substantial duties as generally performed, and whether Unum’s classification fits the work you did |
| “After 24 months, you are disabled only if you are unable to perform the duties of any gainful occupation” | The own-occupation to any-occupation transition, with a transferable skills analysis and labor-market data at the policy’s earnings threshold (often 60 percent of indexed pre-disability earnings) | Testing each occupation against the actual restrictions and the threshold; checking whether the capacity profile came from your physicians or Unum’s reviewer |
| “Your condition is subject to the 24-month limitation for mental illness” or “for self-reported symptoms” | Some Unum policies limit psychiatric disabilities and disabilities based primarily on self-reported symptoms (which may involve conditions such as fibromyalgia, chronic fatigue, headaches, or chronic pain) to 24 months, depending on the policy’s language. | Evidence that the impairment is physical and objectively documented; the policy’s exact language; medical authority on the objective basis of the condition |
| “Your benefit has been reduced by Social Security disability benefits you are receiving or are eligible to receive” | The offset, often estimated before the award | Verification; the reimbursement-agreement alternative; coordination of the SSDI claim; the 2018 ERISA requirement that Unum explain any disagreement with the award |
| “Your disability is excluded under the pre-existing condition provision” | Look-back review of the months before coverage | Record-by-record analysis against the clause’s exact terms |
| “Surveillance and social media activity are inconsistent with your reported limitations” | Field investigation and online research | Context and duration; consistency with restrictions actually claimed; treating-physician statement |
| “We have determined that you are no longer disabled” (after years of payment) | A periodic review that produced a new file review or vocational analysis | The same evidence as an initial appeal, plus the point that nothing in the records changed between the last approval and the termination |
| “We did not receive the requested information” | Short-deadline requests | Complete responses with proof of delivery |
In Evans v. UnumProvident Corp., 434 F.3d 866 (6th Cir. 2006), the Sixth Circuit affirmed a finding that UnumProvident acted arbitrarily and capriciously in terminating disability benefits. The court considered the insurer’s reliance on internal physician file reviews, factual inaccuracies, failure to adequately address reliable medical evidence, and conflict of interest.
What the 2004 agreements required, and why it still matters
The Regulatory Settlement Agreements did not simply fine Unum. They required specific changes in how claims were evaluated, and those changes are a useful checklist for reading a Unum denial letter today:
- Treating physicians. Under the October 2005 amendment, Unum agreed to give significant weight to the opinion of a properly licensed attending physician practicing in the relevant field unless it was not well supported by medically acceptable clinical or diagnostic standards and was inconsistent with other substantial evidence in the record. The claim file had to document specific reasons for rejecting the opinion.
- Social Security awards. Unum agreed to give significant weight to Social Security disability awards unless it had compelling evidence that the award rested on legal error, conflicted with the medical evidence, or applied a different definition of disability. The 2018 ERISA disability-claims amendments separately required insurers to explain their basis for disagreeing with a Social Security disability determination presented to the plan.
- In-house medical reviews. Unum agreed that everyone evaluating a claim would consider all of the claimant’s diagnoses together, and their combined effect on the whole person, rather than one condition at a time.
- Independent examinations. Unum agreed, with limited exceptions, to obtain an independent medical examination when its own physicians disagreed with the attending physician and their opinion would be the basis for a denial, and to tell claimants in writing of their right to request one.
- Governance. Unum added independent directors, created a board Regulatory Compliance Committee and a Regulatory Compliance Unit to audit claims handling, and met quarterly with the lead regulators and the Labor Department.
A denial that discounts the treating physician without a stated reason, disregards a Social Security award, rests on a single-condition file review, or declines an examination the plan permitted is a denial that departs from what Unum agreed to do in 2004. The denial letter is read against the standard Unum itself accepted in 2004, and each departure is documented in the record. In an ERISA appeal, that departure is documented, not argued; the appeal states what the file shows and lets the court compare it to the standard Unum itself accepted.
The ERISA rules Unum must follow
Most Unum group policies are employer-sponsored and governed by ERISA and the Department of Labor’s claims regulation, 29 CFR 2560.503-1:
- The denial letter must state the specific reasons and plan provisions, describe what would perfect the claim, explain the appeal and the right to sue, and, under the 2018 amendments, explain why Unum disagrees with the treating physicians and with any Social Security award.
- The claimant has at least 180 days to appeal; the appeal is mandatory before suit.
- The claimant is entitled to the complete claim file free of charge, including the physician reviews, the vocational analysis, the surveillance, and the internal guidelines relied on.
- New evidence developed during the appeal must be disclosed with time to respond before the appeal is decided.
- The appeal must be decided by someone new, consulting a health professional not involved in the initial denial, within 45 days plus one 45-day extension.
- Violations that are more than minor cost Unum its deference: deemed exhaustion and de novo review under 29 CFR 2560.503-1(l)(2).
Building the appeal against Unum
The appeal is the trial. The federal judge reads the file as Unum closed it and, in most cases, asks only whether Unum’s decision was arbitrary and capricious.
Proving the disability
- Obtain and read the complete claim file. Identify each physician reviewer and specialty, the occupational classification Unum applied, the transferable skills analysis and its assumed capacities, and every record Unum did not have.
- Update the medical record through the appeal date.
- Obtain treating-specialist opinions that answer the reviewers point by point and state function-by-function restrictions against the policy’s definition of disability, regular occupation as normally performed or any gainful occupation at the earnings threshold.
- Add objective testing where the condition allows; for a condition Unum may call “self-reported,” document every objective finding that exists and cite the medical authority on the condition’s objective basis.
- Obtain a vocational assessment addressing the occupation as the policy defines it and each occupation in the transferable skills analysis.
- Include the Social Security decision and its evidence.
- Add statements from family, former supervisors, and coworkers.
Proving the process was unreasonable
- Document the reviewer’s specialty mismatch, the treating opinions discounted without a stated reason, the conditions reviewed one at a time, and Unum’s unexercised right to examine.
- Compare the denial letter to the record and to the 2004 checklist.
- Document every procedural failure.
- Set out the structural conflict of interest under Glenn.
- Write the argument tying the evidence to the policy language and the law.
Preserve the litigation deadline. Some Unum policies contain a three-year contractual limitation period for filing suit, calculated from dates specified in the policy. The applicable period may be enforceable under Heimeshoff v. Hartford, so the deadline must be calculated from the claimant’s actual policy.*. Calculate it from the policy when the denial arrives.
If the appeal is denied
Suit is filed under 29 USC 1132(a)(1)(B) in federal court, in Michigan the Eastern District (Detroit, Ann Arbor, Flint, Bay City) or Western District (Grand Rapids, Kalamazoo, Lansing, Marquette), on the administrative record. If the plan grants Unum discretion, the standard is arbitrary and capricious with the conflict of interest weighed under Glenn; if Unum forfeited deference through procedural violations, de novo. Remedies are the benefits owed with interest and, in the court’s discretion, attorney fees to a claimant who achieves some success on the merits. Remand to Unum for a new decision is a common outcome.
For Unum policies not governed by ERISA, the individual policies Provident and Paul Revere sold to physicians, dentists, and other professionals in large numbers through the 1980s and 1990s, and policies issued to governmental and church employers, Michigan law applies: a jury, discovery, contract damages, and 12 percent penalty interest under MCL 500.2006 on benefits not timely paid. The individual professional policies, many of them “own occupation” to age 65 with no any-occupation transition, were a central subject of the 2004 examination and remain in force for thousands of insureds.
The Social Security connection
Unum requires claimants to apply for Social Security disability, offsets the LTD benefit by the award (and by an estimate before the award, absent a reimbursement agreement), and demands repayment of the overlap when back pay arrives. The SSDI award is also evidence that Unum agreed in 2004 to treat as significant and that the 2018 ERISA rules require it to address in the denial letter. Our SSDI page covers the Social Security claim; the two are handled together.
What to do when Unum denies or terminates your claim
- Note the date you received the letter and count 180 days.
- Read the policy for the contractual limitation period and calculate the deadline for suit.
- Request the complete claim file in writing, citing 29 CFR 2560.503-1(h)(2)(iii), and wait for it before appealing.
- Read the denial against the 2004 checklist: treating physician discounted without a stated reason, Social Security award disregarded, single-condition file review, examination declined.
- Respond to every information request completely, with proof of delivery.
- Do not sign a reimbursement agreement, release, or buyout without advice.
- Keep treating, and assume surveillance and social-media review.
- Call a lawyer before the appeal is filed.
What a disability insurance lawyer does against this insurer
- Determines whether ERISA or Michigan law governs, whether the plan grants discretion, and when the contractual limitation period runs.
- Obtains the claim file and dissects the physician reviews, the occupational classification, and the transferable skills analysis against the 2004 checklist.
- Builds the twelve-part appeal and submits it with proof of delivery before the deadline.
- Coordinates the Social Security claim and manages the offset and the repayment demand.
- Litigates in federal court on the record, or in Michigan court with a jury for individual and other non-ERISA policies, and seeks fees and penalty interest where available.
Long-term disability appeals and lawsuits are handled on a contingency basis: no fee unless benefits are recovered. ATLAW advances case-related expenses, and the fee terms are explained in a written fee agreement before work begins. There is no charge for the initial consultation.
Why Michigan claimants call ATLAW for Unum denials
- Thirteen years serving clients, more than 10,000 cases.
- The appeal built as the trial it is, with the claim file read first.
- Individual professional policies handled under Michigan law, with a jury and penalty interest, where ERISA does not apply.
- Social Security and LTD coordinated.
- Dearborn, and the whole metro area. Our office is at 3 Parklane Blvd., Suite 400W, Dearborn, MI 48126. Clients come from Detroit, Dearborn, Southfield, Warren, Sterling Heights, Troy, Pontiac, Canton, Ann Arbor, and Ypsilanti. We welcome clients to our Dearborn office for a consultation. If you are unable to visit, home or hospital visits can be arranged as needed.
- Languages. Consultations and intake are available in English, Arabic, French, Mandarin, Urdu, and Spanish.
- Fees. Long-term disability appeals and lawsuits are handled on contingency: no fee unless benefits are recovered. ATLAW advances case-related expenses, and the fee terms are explained in a written fee agreement before work begins. The initial consultation is free.











