The Hartford is one of the two largest group disability insurers in the United States. It reached that position in November 2017 by acquiring Aetna’s group life and disability business for $1.45 billion, a transaction The Hartford itself described as making it “the second largest group life and disability insurer,” insuring more than 20 million people. Michigan workers whose employers bought disability coverage from Aetna before 2017, or from The Hartford at any time, are insured by Hartford Life and Accident Insurance Company, the entity that issues the group policies and decides the claims.
The Hartford also gave its name to the Supreme Court decision that every long-term disability claimant should know. In Heimeshoff v. Hartford Life & Accident Insurance Co., decided in 2013, the Court held that a policy’s own deadline for filing suit, in that case three years from the date proof of loss was due, is enforceable even though it begins running before the claimant has finished the mandatory administrative appeal. A Hartford claimant who spends two years in appeals and then looks up the deadline may find it has already passed. The clause is in the policy, and it has to be read on the day the denial letter arrives.
This page explains who your insurer is, how Hartford group disability claims are denied and terminated, the forms and reports particular to this insurer, the ERISA rules that govern the appeal, how the appeal is built, what happens in court, and what a Michigan disability insurance lawyer does. The general law of these claims, ERISA, the administrative record, standard of review, and the Michigan law that applies to non-ERISA policies, is on our long-term disability page; this page assumes it and goes to what is particular to The Hartford.
ATLAW is a Dearborn law firm serving clients for 13 years, with more than 10,000 cases handled. The firm represents Michigan claimants in long-term disability appeals and lawsuits against group disability insurers, including claims insured by The Hartford. Each case is assigned to an ATLAW attorney, and the fee is contingent: no fee unless benefits are recovered.
The Hartford: the facts
| Fact | Detail | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Issuing entity for group disability policies | Hartford Life and Accident Insurance Company is a principal Group Benefits insurer. Other insurers may issue policies administered by The Hartford. | Policy forms |
| Aetna group life and disability acquisition | Announced October 23, 2017; completed November 1, 2017, for $1.45 billion | The Hartford news release; Insurance Journal, Oct. 23, 2017 |
| Scale after the acquisition | “Second largest group life and disability insurer”; more than 20 million customers; Aetna’s book about $2 billion in annual group life and disability premium | The Hartford, as quoted Oct. 23, 2017 |
| Earlier acquisition | CNA’s group benefits business, 2003 | |
| The deadline case | Heimeshoff v. Hartford Life & Accident Ins. Co., 571 U.S. 99 (2013): a plan’s contractual limitation period for suit is enforceable even if it runs before administrative remedies are exhausted, so long as the period is reasonable | Supreme Court |
| Governing law for employer plans | ERISA; 29 CFR 2560.503-1 | Federal law |
| Claimant’s appeal deadline | At least 180 days from receipt of the denial | 29 CFR 2560.503-1(h)(3)(i) |
| Insurer’s appeal decision deadline | 45 days, one 45-day extension | 29 CFR 2560.503-1(i)(3) |
| Standard of review in most cases | Arbitrary and capricious, if the plan grants discretion | Firestone v. Bruch (1989); Metropolitan Life v. Glenn (2008) |
| Penalty interest under a Michigan (non-ERISA) policy | 12% per year | MCL 500.2006 |
The forms and reports particular to Hartford claims
Hartford’s claim files have a vocabulary of their own, and a claimant who understands the documents understands the denial.
The Attending Physician’s Statement (APS) and Physical Capacity Evaluation (PCE). Hartford uses physician-completed medical assessments to evaluate a claimant’s functional limitations. Documented Hartford forms include the Attending Physician’s Statement (APS) and Physical Capacity or Physical Capabilities Evaluation (PCE). Hartford’s published Attending Physician’s Statement includes a section called "Level of Functionality." It asks the treating physician to identify how long the patient can sit, stand, and walk during a workday and to evaluate activities such as lifting, carrying, bending, reaching, and fine manipulation. Certain activities are rated as continuously (5.5–8 hours), frequently (2.5–5.5 hours), occasionally (up to 2.5 hours), or never. The form expressly states that unspecified functional restrictions may be treated as absent. This makes detailed and accurate physician responses important. Incomplete restrictions, unsupported estimates, or inconsistencies between the form and treatment records can affect how Hartford evaluates a claim. An appeal should examine the actual APS, PCE, or other assessment used in the case and identify whether the physician’s conclusions accurately reflect the medical evidence. Additional treating-provider explanations may be appropriate to address pain, fatigue, concentration, attendance, unscheduled breaks, or other functional limitations that the form does not fully capture..
The Employability Analysis Report. When Hartford moves a claim from the own-occupation to the any-occupation definition, typically at 24 months, it commissions an Employability Analysis Report from its vocational rehabilitation unit, which uses occupational software and the capacity profile from the Ability Analysis to identify occupations the claimant can supposedly perform at the policy’s earnings threshold, commonly 60 percent of pre-disability earnings, sometimes indexed. The report names occupations by Dictionary of Occupational Titles code and asserts wage data. The appeal tests each occupation against the claimant’s actual restrictions, the earnings threshold, whether the occupation exists in the claimant’s labor market in the sense the policy requires, and whether the capacity profile the report assumed was the treating physicians’ or the reviewer’s.
Medical-record reviews. Hartford has used physicians and other medical professionals to conduct independent reviews of existing records, sometimes through outside review vendors, without performing another physical examination. These reviews can affect how the insurer interprets treating-provider opinions, diagnostic findings, and work-related restrictions. When challenging a denial, the reviewer’s specialty, the evidence considered, communications with treating providers, and the reasoning supporting the conclusions may be important. In Calvert v. Firstar Finance, Inc., 409 F.3d 286 (6th Cir. 2005), the Sixth Circuit explained that the absence of a physical examination may raise questions about a claim review’s reliability in some circumstances. In Fenwick v. Hartford Life & Accident Insurance Co. (2021), the court applied that principle but upheld Hartford’s decision based on the particular record. The relevant question is not simply whether Hartford used a file review, but whether the overall medical evaluation was adequate and consistent with the available evidence..
The Social Security estimate. Hartford policies offset the LTD benefit by Social Security disability benefits the claimant receives or is estimated to be eligible for. Hartford may reduce the benefit by an estimated SSDI amount before any award, unless the claimant signs a reimbursement agreement promising to repay from the eventual award. When the award arrives, Hartford’s repayment demand follows.
How Hartford claims are denied and terminated
| The letter says | What is usually behind it | What the appeal does |
|---|---|---|
| “The medical information on file does not support functional limitations that would preclude you from performing the essential duties of your occupation” | A Medical Record Review by a non-examining physician, often with an Ability Analysis completed by the reviewer | Treating-specialist opinions on the same grid with clinical support; objective testing; the Sixth Circuit file-review argument where Hartford had the right to examine and did not |
| “Based on the Employability Analysis Report, you are able to perform the following occupations” | The 24-month any-occupation transition | A vocational assessment testing each identified occupation against the actual restrictions, the earnings threshold, and the capacity profile actually supported by the treating physicians |
| “Surveillance conducted on [dates] documented activity inconsistent with your reported limitations” | Field investigation, frequently preceding a termination | Context and duration of the observed activity; consistency with the restrictions actually claimed; treating-physician statement that the activity is within restrictions |
| “Your Attending Physician’s Statement indicates you are able to perform sedentary work” | A physician’s quick completion of the Ability Analysis, or blank boxes read as unrestricted | A corrected, supported statement from the physician explaining the earlier form |
| “Your condition is subject to the mental illness limitation” | The 24-month cap applied to a claim with any psychiatric component | Evidence that the physical impairment is independently disabling; the policy’s exact language |
| “We have reduced your benefit by the estimated amount of Social Security disability benefits for which you may be eligible” | The estimated-offset provision | Election of the reimbursement-agreement alternative where available; verification of the estimate; coordination of the SSDI claim |
| “Your disability is excluded under the pre-existing condition provision” | Look-back review of the months before coverage | Record-by-record analysis against the clause’s exact terms |
| “We did not receive the requested information by [date]” | Short-deadline requests during the claim | Complete responses with proof of delivery; objection where no request was actually made |
The ERISA rules Hartford must follow
Most Hartford group policies are employer-sponsored and governed by ERISA and the Department of Labor’s claims regulation, 29 CFR 2560.503-1:
- The denial letter must state the specific reasons and plan provisions, describe what would perfect the claim, explain the appeal and the right to sue, and, under the 2018 amendments, explain why Hartford disagrees with the treating physicians and with any Social Security award.
- The claimant has at least 180 days to appeal, and the appeal is mandatory before suit.
- The claimant is entitled to the complete claim file free of charge, including the Medical Record Review, the Ability Analysis as completed by any reviewer, the Employability Analysis Report and its underlying data, the surveillance, and the internal guidelines relied on.
- New evidence Hartford develops during the appeal, including a new file review, must be disclosed to the claimant with time to respond before the appeal is decided.
- The appeal must be decided by someone new, consulting a health professional not involved in the initial denial, within 45 days plus one 45-day extension.
- Violations that are more than minor cost Hartford its deference: the claimant is deemed to have exhausted the appeal and the court reviews de novo, under 29 CFR 2560.503-1(l)(2).
Building the appeal against Hartford
The appeal is the trial. The federal judge reads the file as Hartford closed it and, in most cases, asks only whether Hartford’s decision was arbitrary and capricious. The appeal must prove the disability and prove the process was unreasonable.
Proving the disability
- Obtain and read the complete claim file. Identify the Medical Record Review physician and specialty, the Ability Analysis and who completed it, the Employability Analysis Report and its assumed capacity profile, and every record Hartford did not have.
- Update the medical record through the appeal date.
- Obtain treating-specialist opinions that answer Hartford’s reviewer point by point and complete the capacity grid with clinical support, adding the capacities the grid omits.
- Add objective testing where the condition allows: imaging, functional capacity evaluation, neuropsychological testing, cardiopulmonary testing.
- Obtain a vocational assessment that addresses the occupation as the policy defines it and each occupation in the Employability Analysis Report.
- Include the Social Security decision and its evidence.
- Add statements from family, former supervisors, and coworkers.
Proving the process was unreasonable
- Document the reviewer’s specialty mismatch, the treating opinions ignored, and Hartford’s unexercised right to examine the claimant.
- Compare the denial letter to the record.
- Document every procedural failure: late decisions, undisclosed new evidence, requests not made, explanations missing.
- Set out the structural conflict of interest under Glenn.
- Write the argument tying the evidence to the policy language and the law.
Calculate the contractual lawsuit deadline. The policy at issue in Heimeshoff required an ERISA benefits lawsuit to be filed within three years after proof of loss was due. The Supreme Court upheld the reasonable contractual limitation despite its beginning before administrative review was completed. In Rice v. Jefferson Pilot Financial Insurance Co., 578 F.3d 450 (6th Cir. 2009), the Sixth Circuit likewise enforced a contractual three-year limitation measured from when proof of claim was required to be submitted. These decisions establish the legal significance of proof-of-loss provisions, but they do not impose an identical deadline on every Hartford policy. Claimants must review their own plan and calculate the applicable filing period rather than assuming it begins with the final denial..
The Heimeshoff deadline is the contractual limit on filing suit, and it should be calculated first, before the appeal is planned, because the period may already be running while the appeal is prepared.
If the appeal is denied
Suit is filed under 29 USC 1132(a)(1)(B) in federal court, in Michigan the Eastern District (Detroit, Ann Arbor, Flint, Bay City) or Western District (Grand Rapids, Kalamazoo, Lansing, Marquette), on the administrative record. If the plan grants Hartford discretion, the standard is arbitrary and capricious with the conflict of interest weighed under Glenn; if Hartford forfeited deference through procedural violations, de novo. Remedies are the benefits owed with interest and, in the court’s discretion, attorney fees to a claimant who achieves some success on the merits. Remand to Hartford for a new decision is a common outcome.
For Hartford policies not governed by ERISA, individual policies and policies issued to governmental and church employers, Michigan law applies: a jury, discovery, contract damages, and 12 percent penalty interest under MCL 500.2006 on benefits not timely paid when the claim was not reasonably in dispute.
The Social Security connection
Hartford requires claimants to apply for Social Security disability, offsets the benefit by the award (and by an estimate of it before the award, absent a reimbursement agreement), and demands repayment of the overlap when back pay arrives. The SSDI award is also evidence: an insurer that required the application, took the offset, and disregarded the award’s finding of disability has created the inconsistency that courts weigh in finding arbitrariness, and the 2018 ERISA rules require Hartford to explain its disagreement with the award in the denial letter. Our SSDI page covers the Social Security claim; the two claims are handled together.
What to do when Hartford denies or terminates your claim
- Note the date you received the letter and count 180 days.
- Read the policy for the contractual limitation period and calculate the deadline for suit from the date proof of loss was due, not from the denial.
- Request the complete claim file in writing, citing 29 CFR 2560.503-1(h)(2)(iii), including the Employability Analysis Report and the Medical Record Review, and wait for it before appealing.
- Do not let your physician complete another Hartford form without reviewing the first one. The grid matters.
- Respond to every information request completely, with proof of delivery.
- Do not sign a reimbursement agreement, release, or buyout without advice; ask whether the reimbursement agreement is the better alternative to an estimated offset.
- Keep treating, and assume surveillance.
- Call a lawyer before the appeal is filed.
What a disability insurance lawyer does against this insurer
- Determines whether ERISA or Michigan law governs, whether the plan grants discretion, and when the contractual limitation period runs.
- Obtains the claim file and dissects the Medical Record Review, the Ability Analysis, and the Employability Analysis Report.
- Builds the twelve-part appeal and submits it with proof of delivery before the deadline.
- Coordinates the Social Security claim and manages the estimated offset, the reimbursement agreement, and the repayment demand.
- Litigates in federal court on the record, or in Michigan court with a jury for non-ERISA policies, and seeks fees and penalty interest where available.
Long-term disability appeals and lawsuits are handled on a contingency basis: no fee unless benefits are recovered. ATLAW advances case-related expenses, and the fee terms are explained in a written fee agreement before work begins. There is no charge for the initial consultation.
Why Michigan claimants call ATLAW for Hartford denials
- Thirteen years serving clients, more than 10,000 cases.
- Hartford’s own documents answered on their own terms: the capacity grid completed with clinical support, the Employability Analysis Report tested occupation by occupation.
- Social Security and LTD coordinated, including the estimated offset.
- Dearborn, and the whole metro area. Our office is at 3 Parklane Blvd., Suite 400W, Dearborn, MI 48126. Clients come from Detroit, Dearborn, Southfield, Warren, Sterling Heights, Troy, Pontiac, Canton, Ann Arbor, and Ypsilanti. We welcome clients to our Dearborn office for a consultation. If you are unable to visit, home or hospital visits can be arranged as needed.
- Languages. Consultations and intake are available in English, Arabic, French, Mandarin, Urdu, and Spanish.
- Fees. Long-term disability appeals and lawsuits are handled on contingency: no fee unless benefits are recovered. ATLAW advances case-related expenses, and the fee terms are explained in a written fee agreement before work begins. The initial consultation is free.











